A question sometimes pops up in my mind and most of the times dies unanswered......are we out of the age of British Colonial Rule yet?
And something as common as the word Tax makes me all the more confused.....May be some one more aware of this social event, can throw some light on my ignorant soul. ...
We heard that under British rule we- the Indians paid taxes in terms of crops and so on. And then there was revolution against slavery. We watched movies like Lagaan and whistled in the theater to see some ordinary villagers' revolt against unfair means to collect Lagaan(taxes). But are we capable of such revolt in our lives today? Or the slavery has gone so deep inside our blood that we don't even realise what is fair!!!!!!!!!!!!
In India like in other countries we pay certain amount of tax on our earnings every financial year. Just in yesterday's news paper a read the column explaining how much a couple earning 25/20 Lakh p/a will pay in taxes post the 2010 budget. Guess what the figure comes to? Rs. 5,57,354 p/a. I'm not an expert to scrutinise every item that brings the this figure out. But my question is what do we get in return? ............... a sense of insecurity about our future? Headache over medical expenditure, a chest pain to hear our children's school fee, sleepless nights thinking about the EMIs to cover our heads, or shear panic to visit a local restaurant as some terrorist might wait there with a bomb?
Say for example, if a person working in an MNC like many do in modern India, earns 10 Lakhs/pa for 20 years of his life; he is paying 30% of his earnings in taxes i.e Rs 3 Lakhs/year, so in 20 years he is paying Rs 60 Lakhs in taxes alone, leave aside the hard work he has to do to obtain that figure out of his employer- doesn't he have the right to ask for free medical cover of Rs 10 Lakhs for his life, or Free education cover for his children for the same amount if anything happens to him, isn't it fair for him to ask for financial security from the Govt. post retirement or if he loses his job?Above all is it too much for him to ask for security against terror attack when a considerable amount of his earning is supposed to be spent on the country's defense? I understand if a govt employee like my parents are, doesn't revolt against taxes as he knows he will at least get pension when his hey days are over. But what about the rest???????
Paying Tax is inevitable in every country, without which no administration can be run....but in other countries, people know what they are paying for.....because they enjoy the value for their money in the name of social security, medical cover, free education and so on.
Is is the same in India as well? Isn't it time that we ask the question to ourselves and our leaders? We pay taxes but we hardly have decent roads to drive on.....we pay taxes but 10 young men enter our financial capital and kill hundreds when our defense is defenseless.....to top it all we clap to see an entire force killing a handful of terrorists after they have taken hundreds of innocent lives. Kudos to our tolerant spirit.... we pay taxes and every night have icy shivers rundown our spine fearing who will pay EMIs on home loan if we lose our job.....we pay taxes and we pay bag full of money just to provide for the basic education for our children.....we pay taxes and we pay to get entertained because we are not supposed to get rid of these burden even for a day......we pay taxes and we pay extra to ensure our 1st child is born under at least clean condition(hope some of you have been to the maternity ward of a Govt. hospital to understand what I mean)..............so we pay.....we pay.....and we pay..the list goes on.....but are we paid back in terms of basic amenities at least? Silence is the best answer I get......
However, we get to watch 200+ channels on T.V(for a cost though)....India is progressing........but is it a trick of the system to keep our minds engaged in trivial things like a dance reality show...so that we remain blind- folded against more serious issues of our society? Isn't it time to ask the question to ourselves before we can ask our country leaders no matter which political party they belong to? We have enough time to argue over the issue of whether a certain film should be screened or not whether a certain players should be allowed to come to our country or not....but alas we don't have enough time to argue over our rights to live our lives the way we deserve instead of just spending it the way we are forced to......long live Indian democracy.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
heyii wow girl...dint know the petite lady has such turmoil in her head..m glad you writing it all down,especially cuz you are good at this..keep it up sanju..really
ReplyDeletethanks Sul....
ReplyDeleteGood start Sanju and a reality well portrayed..keep writing girl...way to go!
ReplyDeletenow you gotto hit the roads with a jhanda..but sanju you have to agree with me that India has changed tremendously in the past 20years. The abject poverty on the roads that we used to see as children is gone for the most part. Even slum-dwellers have access to commodities that middle classes would aim for. And some of this has been possible because of the system.Agree or not?
ReplyDeleteWhen was the lats time we went to interior villages to see the actual India sattu? The change is somewhat an eye-wash. I'm not saying there hasn't been any change, however, is it really enough for a country like India? When was the last time an Indian came out with a revolutionary idea or some life-changing invention? Is it because we don't have the potential? I don't think so ...it's because we hardly have any freedom of thought or of choice? U know there is a company in India that makes an electric car called Reva? But it's too expensive for a two seater coz most of it's components are imported from abroad.....do u mean to say we can't make it here and solve the increasing problem of liquid fuel? But we don't try because Govt. earns more revenue from Maruti and Tata....Do u think it's progress?
ReplyDeleteFully agreed on the original post.... Paying taxes is inevitable... no complaints against that.... it's our small bit to do something for the progress of modern India!!
ReplyDeleteBut the point is, it hurts too much seeing the tax payers' money being wasted in our country!! A mere simple example, road dividers being constructed/destructed every now and then... where does the money come from.... of course from us... And what do the tax payers get in return?.. More taxes... House Tax, water Tax, entertainment tax, service tax, tax tax tax.... the list continues...
I believe, it's easiest to account for the money being earned in service sector and we are being penalized for that alone to some extent.... leave apart the corruption existing in our country...
Yes Sanju point conceded, a look at the abject poverty in which most of rural india lives is such a matter of shame
ReplyDeleteGood article ... Very well expressed ... has the potency to make people think ... Glad to see you in a different perspective ... you have defined the problem ... now root cause analysis would be required ... and then how can we be part of the solution ... if we are not then we are part of the problem ... there is no midway ... With your pace and energy i am sure you will reach there.
ReplyDelete